Home Podcast Blog Bookstore Apply For Coaching Training Library Replens Mastermind Sourcing School About Us Help Center Login

Build Your E-Commerce Brand With These 7 Master Methods

May 02, 2024

Legendary money manager Bill Miller once said, 

"There are three sources of competitive advantage in investing: informational, analytical, or behavioral."

We can apply this to the real world of competitive marketing and say, there are...

3 Sources Of Competitive Advantage In Building Your Brand

Informational Advantage: You can win by simply knowing more about the business than your competitors. It's very common for entrenched competitors to face new upstarts. That can be troubling. One way they win is by simply knowing more about the business than their younger rivals. What can they know? 

  • Customer buying behavior (what will sell and what won't)
  • Pricing strategies that work in that niche
  • Supplier options and challenges
  • Seasonality
  • Margins
  • A million other small but important facts that give the entrenched marketer an advantage - as they simply wait and watch the upstart rival make predictable mistakes.

What can the new upstarts know that serves as a competitive advantage? It's a smaller / harder list, which is why it's always easier to play defense than offense, but the list could include:

  • Missing aspects of the entrenched competitor's offerings (what they're not offering)
  • Details of customer dissatisfaction
  • New technology options that the entrenched competitor can't easily switch to
  • Consumer trends that might favor a radical new approach

Analytical Advantage: turning information into a real competitive advantage is much harder work.

This could be called the wisdom advantage. Two competitors can see the exact same opportunity, the exact same consumer behavior, the exact same market conditions, and come up with completely different opinions about what they should do. 

This is also why people study Warren Buffett (and his partner Charlie Munger) and consider him the greatest investor of all time. Because when everyone sees the same information - he tends to come up with a much higher quality of analysis than other people. Many of his most famous quotes touch on this issue in some way or another. Charlie Munger has some zingers too. Some of my favorites are, 

"Time is the friend of the wonderful business, it's the enemy of the lousy business."

"We don't have huge returns in mind, but we do have in mind never losing anything."

"If you hand me a gun with a million chambers in it and there is a bullet in one and say, 'how much do you want to pull the the trigger once', I'm not going to pull it. You can name any sum you want on the upside and it doesn't do anything for me, and I think the downside is fairly clear."

"What you're looking for is some way to get one good idea a year, and then ride it to its full potential."

"It's better to have a part interest in the hope diamond than to own all of a rhinestone."

Behavioral Advantage: So we can know things - we can analyze things - but ultimately we have to act, and it is our actions that prospects and customers will judge. Do we act in a way that serves the customer with exceptional results? When it comes to advantages of behavior, there are only three paths. 

  1. Do more of what the competition does - be the most complete provider, expand the offer, add more in some way).
  2. Do less of what the competition does - remove unpleasant aspects of the product or buying experience, eliminate unnecessary aspects, make a minimalist version, make it simpler in some way.
  3. Do it differently than the competition does - offer a unique option, experience, or approach.

Think about how Walmart, Target, and Costco each approach selling their items. They couldn't be more different, but each system works. Walmart offers a few choices in a massive number of product categories. Target emphasizes upscale options that actually very affordable. Costco offers an extremely limited set of product choices in very large quantity packaging, for (per unit) bargain prices. More, less, different.

4 Categories Of Consumer Preference

Author Michael Gerber discusses 4 categories of preference. These can be applied to our work as e-commerce sellers and brand builders. They are,

Visual Preference: Customers can choose your item because it looks different. This can take shape at numerous levels including,

  • The visual look of the product design
  • The packaging of the product.
  • The product photography.
  • The website photography and graphics

Emotional Preference: Customers can choose you, your product, or your brand because they bond with your at an emotional level. What types of emotional bonds are customers frequently looking for? They can include,

  • A business that shares my social values (faith, family, politics)
  • A business that is the market leader (a winner)
  • A business that makes the experience fun 
  • A business that appeals to my sense of adventure, need for danger, or risk
  • A business that eliminates risk of a bad outcome
  • A business that makes me feel pampered, special, or wealthy

Functional Preference: Customers can choose you because your product or service is functionally superior to the competition. You have a better mouse trap, better features, better systems. This is where most product designers spend their time and energy. The problem with this category as a competitive advantage is, competitors can generally copy what you do. So it's hard to create a long-term competitive advantage on the back of functional preference alone. A fun example of functional preference is the consumer shift from Encyclopedias to Wikipedia. It was an interesting change in functional preference. The step included,

  1. Encyclopedia Britannica ruled the world for 244 years with their high-value books. They were a luxury item. In 1990 their sales peaked at 650 million dollars a year.
  2. In the 1980s Microsoft had approached the managers at Encyclopedia Britannica and asked if they would partner on an electronic version. The offer was declined because they felt a CDROM could never compete with the high quality of their books.
  3. Microsoft launched a CD Encyclopedia called Encarta in 1993 and run it until 2009. It took massive market share away from Britannica, leading to their near extinction.
  4.  In 2001 entrepreneur Jimmy Wales launched Wikipedia, a free online encyclopedia, run by volunteers and managed by a non-profit foundation. It became the eventual winner.

Financial Preference: Customers can choose you because you are financially different than the competition. What are your options? They are broader than you might initially expect. A few exceptional books on this topic include; Free - The Future Of A Radical Price and Priceless - The Myth Of Fair Value. Your options can include,

  • Become the low-cost leader (very hard to survive on for the long-term)
  • Become an ultra-premium provider (if your product, packaging, and presentation can support it)
  • Make the product cost zero (give away the product) and charge for something else entirely
  • Create a monthly subscription (recurring payment) version that eliminates customer decision-making

Creating Your Unique Approach. No two businesses, websites, or brands can truly be identical. The real question is, will you use information, analysis, and action to create something that stands out visually, emotionally, functionally, and financially? I hope so - the world needs more interesting options!

Get A Free 30 Minute Consultation When You Apply For Personal Coaching: As part of the coaching application process we offer a free 30 minute consultation. It is our opportunity to meet each other and discover together if coaching is a good fit. If you're ready to get our personal help. Learn more here. 

If you'd like additional training and coaching to achieve your Shopify goals, consider applying for our coaching program today!

Grateful for the chance to be of help,

Jason & Kyle


50% Complete

Two Step

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.